Article Archive

Columbus talk-show host working as guard shoots two

The NBC4 Columbus is reporting that Columbus radio talk-show host Cornell McCleary shot two men, seriously injuring one of them, last night while working as a security guard at an East Side apartment complex.

According to the report, police questioned McCleary, 51, then released him without filing charges.

From the story:

    The shooting happened at about 6 p.m. at an apartment complex on
    Vineshire Drive on the city's east side.

    The guard said the men were causing problems, refused to leave and then
    became violent, and that he acted in self-defense, Garcia reported.

    Police said the incident started as an exchange of words but quickly
    turned into a gunfight.

    A woman said her nephew had just returned home from work when he
    allegedly was approached by a group of young men. She said he was
    approached because he was wearing a red shirt.

    "It's a damn shame that you can't wear what you want to wear," she said.
    "The guy approached my nephew thinking he was in a gang."

    That's when police said a security officer at the apartment complex got
    involved. Columbus Police Detective Jim Day said the guard told the
    group of men to leave, but they didn't.

    Day said the guard was punched in the face. That's when the guard said
    he pulled his gun and shot the two men he said were attacking him.

According to the story, both men were hospitalized in stable condition.

The Columbus Dispatch's coverage of this story, reporter Matthew Marx reports that McCleary, who hosts a talk show Sunday nights on WTVN (610 AM), "has a weapons permit" and is a licensed armed guard.

It is unclear whether Marx was trying to say that McCleary is a concealed handgun license-holder when referring to a "weapons permit," but several OFCC supporters have advised us that McCleary has identified himself as a CHL-holder several times on his radio show.

OFCC will continue to follow this story.

Toledo officials offer contradictory statements on park ban challenge

Judging by recent coverage in the Toledo Blade, city officials are beginning to contradict themselves publicly as they struggle to decide how to deal with an activist who has announced he will challenge the city's ban on carrying firearms for self-defense in parks next week.

Yesterday, Toledo City Councilman Wilma Brown told the newspaper she would try to stop the parks department from issuing a permit for the gathering by claiming it carrying firearms in the park would be a political statement. She said that is prohibited in a public park.

But today, city law director Barb Herring contradicted Brown, announcing that advocates of the state's concealed-carry law can gather at Toledo's Ottawa Park next week, even though the event's organizer does not have a permit.

From the story:

    Bruce Beatty does not need a permit as long as it remains a small gathering April 9, city Law Director Barb Herring said. Still, Mr. Beatty's plan to carry his 45-caliber, semi-automatic handgun to the park won't be tolerated, she and others said.

    "We want to be sure that our citizens feel safe in the parks. If need be, we will provide an appropriate response," Mayor Jack Ford said in a written statement.

If Mayor Ford truly believes bans can prevent criminal activity, it is cause to wonder why he didn't order the posting of "NO RAPING CHILDREN" signs in Toledo parks last summer after an 11-year-old girl was sexually assaulted at Toledo's Danny Thomas Park.

That aside, other contradictions by city officials are creeping into news stories.

Click on the "Read More..." link below for more.

Op-Ed: Only a gun could have stopped Jeff Weise

March 30, 2005
St. Paul (MN) Pioneer Press

By Mark Yost

In the week since teenage gunman Jeff Weise walked into Red Lake Senior High School and killed five students, a teacher and a security guard before killing himself, the usual voices from the usual precincts have been asking: What can we do to keep this from happening next time? How about arming security guards, as well as a handful of administrators and teachers who volunteer to be properly trained?

I can hear the gasps echoing from Mac-Groveland to Crocus Hill. But if we think any legislation is going to stop the next Jeff Weise, we're fooling ourselves. Indeed, the idea that with the right legislation and an unlimited pot of money we can take the risk out of any of life's endeavors is simply wrong.

There's no arguing that Weise had a tragic life. And the search for possible explanations and missed clues runs the gamut. Was it the music he listened to, the movies he watched, the video games he played, the Web sites he visited or the medication he took (the most plausible)?

As for possible remedies, typical were those posited on these pages by Dan Gartrell, a former Head Start teacher at Red Lake. According to him, Weise would have been just fine if teachers "had time to greet students in the morning, easing them through conflicts since the previous day that may be getting them down." He went on to suggest that we need full-time mental health professionals in our schools, from preschool through college.

What's ironic is that Gartrell's advice came just two weeks after another professor — Robin Magee of Hamline University — took St. Paul police to task for carrying Tasers in schools. She argued that police need no more than "a stern command" to control unruly schoolchildren. Red Lake Senior High School security guard Derrick Brun tried that. His funeral was Monday.

Click here for more of this excellent commentary from the St. Paul (MN) Pioneer Press.

Gun Grabber's Letter to the Editor:

Fewer guns in fewer hands - not the opposite
…"Instead of expressing sympathy for felons, Morris, how about showing concern for the nearly 30,000 victims of gun violence every year in the United States - the highest rate of gun deaths in the developed world? How about speaking out against immunity for gun manufacturers and dealers (once again before Congress)? How about advocating for an assault weapons ban, or for closing the gun-show loophole, or for other sensible measures to keep guns out of the hands of criminals, terrorists and disturbed children?"

How about telling us how any of that would have stopped Jeff Weise, Karen?

LTE: Incident exaggerated

March 29, 2005
Dayton Daily News

Re "Bullet-riddled block pleads for help," March 14:

Only a city boy writer for the Dayton Daily News could:

• Make a .22 rifle into an automatic weapon.
• Pretend that school buses are targets.
• Turn one .22 slug into a bullet-riddled neighborhood.
• Make a .22 hole in a window look a foot wide.
• Ignore countless shootings in Dayton, but denigrate Waynesville country folk.

When did a broken window in Dayton last make front-page news? Has the DDN's anti-gun stance made Dayton safer?

I have to admit, the reporter's writing is colorful. The editor of this foolish yellow journalism had to know what a crock he was stirring. We dumb country folks know hot-pink Big Brother socialism when we read it.

I have been a target shooter with a good backup: a hill 80 feet high. I found that my bullets went underground, skipped along the top of some shallow shale rock, re-emerged at a high angle, and went over the hilltop. The day I found out, I complained to the neighbor on the other side of the hill that I could hear his ricochets going over my head. He told me that mine did the same thing to him. We readjusted our shooting. We are still friends. Nobody was a criminal.

We didn't need a posse, the sheriff, the school superintendent, and the Dayton Daily News to fix the problem.

Chuck Layton
Wayne Twp.

Philly Inquirer Op-Ed: Right-to-carry law is the way to go

March 29, 2005
Philadelphia Inquirer

By John R. Lott Jr.

While murder rates have been falling or have been flat for years in the rest of the country, Philadelphia's rate has been rising. Last year's murder rate was the highest since 1993, and Philadelphia replaced Chicago, the perennial leader, as the top 10 largest city with the highest murder rate. With 85 murders in the first 88 days of 2005, the city's murder rate is well ahead of even last year's.

Mayor John Street's solution? He's doing little about fixing the city's declining arrest rates for murder. Instead, he blames the law-abiding citizens who have permits to carry concealed handguns. He announced on Thursday that the city will deliberately begin delaying issuing new concealed handgun permits. Gov. Rendell's proposed crime task force promises to examine the issue further.

No reporters seem to have asked Street or Rendell the obvious question: If permit-holders are the problem, how many of those 85 murders were caused by a person with a permitted concealed handgun? When I asked, the city police and mayor's office were unable or unwilling to answer that question, but my guess is zero.

Click here for the entire op-ed, originally published in the Philadelphia Inquirer.

Ohioans For Concealed Carry Issues 2005 Ohio Concealed Handgun License Report

For Immediate Release
March 29, 2005

OhioCCW is a success!

CLEVELAND - Ohio's Concealed Handgun License program is one of the most successful consumer protection programs in state history, according to a first-ever report released today by Ohioans For Concealed Carry, the state's largest grassroots organization focused solely on protecting and improving Ohioans' right to bear arms for self-defense.

In the 2005 Ohio Concealed Handgun License Report, OFCC observes that, according to numbers released by the state Attorney General, about 175 people are taking advantage of this program daily by applying for licenses. As we mark the first anniversary of the law's activation, approximately 50,000 Ohioans are now licensed to carry concealed handguns for their defense and security.

"The results speak for themselves," said Jeff Garvas, founder and president of OFCC. "Ohioans have applied for licenses at a rate far exceeding other states with recently-passed concealed carry reform laws. Furthermore, they are proving to be an even more law-abiding group of people than even we predicted they would be. This report gives the General Assembly all the proof they need that some of the egregious restrictions forced into the bill by anti-gun lobbyists, and the politicians beholden to them, must be removed."

In addition to an analysis on license-issuance and how various appointment schemes utilized by a few sheriffs are influencing application rates, the report analyzes claims made by the gun ban lobby prior to passage of the law, and compares them to comments made about the implementation of the law by Ohio's sheriffs.

"This report puts it in black and white," said OFCC PAC Chairman Jim Irvine. "Legislators put their faith in the citizens of Ohio to be as responsible as those in other states, and their faith has been rewarded. Additionally, the report makes it clear beyond any doubt that the adjacent county provision is essential to ensuring a few sheriffs cannot completely restrict citizens' ability to apply for a license."

As Ohio's primary concealed carry reform advocate, OFCC has been and continues to be in constant contact with Rep. Jim Aslanides, and other lawmakers, to assure that the rights of Ohio's law-abiding gun owners, and our members, are protected.

It is accepted by most law enforcement agencies, attorneys and pro-gun organizations that the open carry, or "plain sight", provision for motor vehicles is a legal black hole that is in desperate need of change. Most other states allow concealed firearms in cars, and have experienced no threat to law enforcement. Ohio's gun owners should be afforded the same right.

We are also working to remove the Media Access Loophole provision, which is currently being abused by newspapers and television stations statewide.

Finally, because many municipal governments are currently enforcing gun control laws restricting Ohio's CHL law, which was enacted as a general law of the state, Ohio needs to pass legislation stressing that Ohio's self-defense initiatives preempt all local gun control.

Ohioans For Concealed Carry looks forward to continuing our work with Representative Aslanides, and hope that Governor Taft recognizes that the current law is in need of reform.

Click here to download (.pdf file) OFCC's 2005 Ohio Concealed Handgun License Report.

Anti-self-defense GOP candidate picks up dubious endorsement

ChannelCincinnati.com is reporting that Ohio gubernatorial-hopeful Betty Montgomery, who opposes Ohioans' right to bear arms for self-defense, has picked up an endorsement from another person with a checkered past when it comes to concealed carry issues.

According to the report, Hamilton County Sheriff Simon Leis has given his support to Ohio Auditor of State Betty Montgomery. Additionally, Leis has been selected to run Montgomery's campaign for governor in Hamilton County.

Concealed-carry advocates will recall that it was Sheriff Leis who was the target of a lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of Ohio's 150-year-old concealed carry ban.

Since passage of the law recognizing the right of citizens to bear arms for self-defense, Leis and a few other urban sheriffs have made news by enforcing restrictive appointment procedures for CHL applicants, which have resulted in a reduction in the numbers of licensees in these counties. Leis also recently told county commissioners he was "totally opposed" to having secret shoppers check his office for quality of service.

Is your pro-concealed carry sheriff supporting Betty Montgomery? If you care about your self-defense rights, you'll find out, and if they are, ask them why!

Related Stories:
2nd Amendment among Betty’s website ''keywords'', but content nonexistent

Betty Montgomery to OFCC Coor.: No CCW because of ''dastardly'' attacks on cops

Letter to OFCC: Montgomery confronted at Republican meeting over anti-CCW stance

State Sen. Joy Padgett endorses Jim Petro for Governor

Headline: "Blackwell poll shows he is pick of GOP"

Man plans to test gun ban in Toledo parks

The Toledo Blade is reporting* that a Toledo-area man is planning to test the city's ban on firearms in parks by hosting a gathering at Toledo's Ottawa Park to celebrate the first anniversary party of Ohio's concealed-carry law at noon April 9, while carrying his 45-caliber semi-automatic handgun in violation of the city's ban on guns in its parks.

From the story:

    April 8 marks the first anniversary of Ohio's concealed-carry law, and [Bruce] Beatty is hoping for a legal show-down. Under the law, Ohio sheriffs shall issue permits to qualifying citizens who wish to carry a concealed firearm.

    Since the law passed, several cities, including Toledo, have issued orders or passed ordinances restricting guns on public properties, such as parks. Private employers have the right under the law to restrict guns on their premises by posting signs notifying employees and the public.

    But a spokesman for Ohio Attorney General Jim Petro's office last year said such local policies appear to be in conflict with the state's concealed-carry law and therefore were not valid. In fact, some cities have rescinded their orders restricting guns in public areas.

The story goes on to say that the City is contemplating ways to stop Beatty's event. One suggestion raised is to deny a permit to gather at the park.

Again, from the story:

    Mr. Beatty, who has ordered a sheet cake in the shape of a 45-caliber handgun, said he's not daunted because he believes he has Ohio law on his side.

    "Bottom line is this: I'm starting to take it extremely personally that politicians and bureaucrats keep comparing law-abiding, tax-paying, good citizens to criminals," he said. "I'm tired of being slandered over the issue."

*WARNING - this Toledo Blade story contains a factual error. In her story, reporter Robin Erb states that Attorney General Jim Petro is backing the City of Clyde in a lawsuit brought by Ohioans For Concealed Carry.

But as regular readers of this website will recall, Petro actually filed a motion to intervene in our lawsuit against the City of Clyde after the city argued Ohio's concealed handgun license law is unconstitutional. Petro argues AGAINST the city - stating that the law is constitutional in all respects.

Click here to read OFCC's coverage of Petro's filing, and to download Petro's actual court documents.

OFCC has sent a request for a retraction to Ms. Erb. Additionally, Attorney General Petro's spokesperson, Kim Norris, has told OFCC today that she has also contacted Ms. Erb to ask for an immediate correction to be made.

UPDATE: The Toledo Blade has corrected its online story, and has confirmed with OFCC that a correction will be published in tomorrow's print edition.

LTE: Gun-safety program should be mandatory

March 29, 2005
Columbus Dispatch

It’s only a matter of time before we hear anti-gun pundits thumping their chests over the second-grader who found a handgun and brought it to school.

Instead of answers to the problem, they’ll use this incident to further their agenda to ban more guns, as if that is prevention. What we need is statewide prevention through mandatory education.

We will never be able to guarantee that a child will never find a firearm, as in this case. What is important is the fact that at least three children saw the firearm and not one of them did anything to prevent this tragedy, likely because they didn’t know better.

Ohio’s lawmakers approved funding for schools to offer the National Rifle Association’s Eddie Eagle Program to kids of this age. The program should be implemented immediately as mandatory education statewide. The program never shows a firearm or pushes firearm ownership. It teaches children who find a firearm a very simple mantra: STOP! Don’t touch. Leave the area. Tell an adult. We teach children to stop, drop and roll if they catch on fire, so why not this? The Eddie Eagle program has been adopted by other states as mandated statewide education, and it should be in Ohio, too. As the antigun pundits would say: If it saves just one child...

Jeff Garvas
President, Ohioans For Concealed Carry
Macedonia

Op-Ed: Gun laws won't protect you from someone bent on violence

March 26, 2005
Salt Lake Tribune

By W. Clark Aposhian

We at Utah Self-Defense Instructors' Network (US-DIN) are deeply saddened at the senseless loss of life that occurred last week at Red Lake High School in Minnesota.

This situation, like other recent mass shootings, is frustrating to us in that we believe they are largely preventable.

This is yet another shooting in another place ignorantly perceived as safe because of signs and policies that prohibit weapons. Yet these places take little, if any, affirmative action to ensure safety, let alone allowing for lawful self-defense. They pay lip service to security procedures and personnel and place "feel good" signs restricting weapons.

These "victim disarmament zones" are actually worse than doing nothing as they take the attention off the real problems. They further a sense of complacency with respect to security. Ignorantly we assume a sign stating "No Guns Allowed" will protect us.

I look forward to an enlivening and enlarging of the debate regarding firearms in schools. US-DIN has never been more committed to maintaining the ability for lawful concealed carry in Utah's schools and elsewhere.

Utah, as one of few states that allow concealed carry in schools, is watched carefully as a "laboratory" of sorts for concealed carry in these environments. Concealed weapons have been allowed in schools since 1995 that has been recently re-enforced with legislation. We have also resisted efforts that would have mitigated lawful self-defense in schools and churches.

Click here to read Mr. Aposhian's entire column in the Salt Lake Tribune.