Article Archive

Talk-show host says he shot 2 men while under siege

The Columbus Dispatch has published more detailed information on CHL-holder Cornell McCleary, who shot two men Wednesday night after he was punched in the face and surrounded by a threatening group of about 10 men.

From the story:

    None of the men appeared to be armed, but "there’s no doubt in my mind they would have killed somebody," said McCleary, 51, who runs a security company and hosts a Sunday night talk show on WTVN (610 AM).

    "This was a mob situation," he said.

    With his .380-caliber semiautomatic pistol, McCleary shot the two men standing closest to him. He said one had just punched him and the other was about to attack. The gunfire sent the crowd running into a nearby apartment, he said.

According to the news story, the confrontation occurred at 5:55 p.m. while McCleary was working as a security guard for Rustic Ridge Apartments on Vineshire Drive.

Police told the Dispatch it started when a group of men threatened a couple who live at the East Side complex.

Again, from the story:

    "We’re going to kill you," members of the group told the man, McCleary said. "I kept telling them to leave the property."

    When McCleary tried to intervene, police said, more men showed up, and one of them punched McCleary in the face.

    "The guy cold-cocked me," he said.

    Then McCleary began firing.

    It was the first time in his 23 years as a security guard that he’s had to shoot, McCleary said.

    "It’s a new breed," he said of his alleged attackers. "They don’t need a reason."

The newspaper reports that the two men who were shot — Kevin Gullick, 36, and Mark Harmon, 20 — were taken to Grant Medical Center. Gullick was listed in serious condition last night; Harmon was released Wednesday night.

The newspaper reports that police questioned McCleary after the incident and released him. No one has been charged, and detectives continue to investigate.

NOTE: The Dispatch's reporters seem to be having a problem with using terminology that correctly describes Mr. McCleary's status as a concealed handgun license-holder.

In the newspapers' two stories on this issue, reporters Matt Marx and Alayna DeMartini have erroniously referred to McCleary's CHL as a "weapons permit". And in this latest story, DeMartini included a strange observation that McCleary is "up to date on all of his firearms training, a spokesman from the Ohio Department of Public Safety said."

Since Ohio's concealed carry law is only one year old, and since Ohio law does not require re-qualification for six years, doesn't that go without saying?

LTE: Media Access Loophole not used for reasons you claimed

Ohio's newspapers continue to offer various and sundry excuses for why they should be allowed to continue treated law-abiding citizens as though they are sex offenders, suspicious neighbors in need of being watched. The following letter to the Marion Star has not (yet?) been published in the newspaper, but as it does an excellent job of highlighting the lie behind their claims for the necessity of the Media Access Loophole, we are happy to share it here.

March 26, 2005

Editor Thomas T. Graser
The Marion Star
150 Court Street
Marion, Ohio 43302

Dear Mr. Graser;

Reasonable people can agree to disagree in a reasonable manner. I respectfully disagree with your editorial of March 20, 2005 regarding possible changes to Ohio's Concealed Carry Law. Your editorial states that such changes are unnecessary. I believe that your stance on this issue is incorrect.

It is important for our legislators to tweak and improve the law. I trust that they will take this responsibility seriously. Some newspapers in Ohio have failed to follow the intent of the law. I have discussed this problem with a number of legislators, and shared my displeasure with the manner in which big city newspapers have printed the names and address of concealed carry permit holders.

The media access provision was added to the legislation so journalists could easily ascertain whether criminals had obtained a concealed carry permit prior to committing their crimes. To date, I have read only one article in the print media regarding inappropriate actions on the part of a concealed carry permit holder. That case was a traffic stop wherein no one was injured.

The media prints stories about motorcycle accidents and generally the last line of the story notes whether or not the accident victims are wearing helmets. Likewise, the last line of stories of automobile accidents advises whether the victims were wearing seat belts. I believe these are legitimate components of responsible media coverage.

Last Sunday, you also asked what we like in the newspaper. Here's what I would like: whenever a criminal is arrested after using a handgun in a crime, please note in the story whether the criminal has taken to trouble of obtaining a concealed carry permit, i.e., has taken and passed the class; filed fingerprints; submitted the application and fee; and received the license, after having been vetted and approved. That too, I believe, is a legitimate component of responsible media coverage.

Sincerely,

William S. Lee

CLICK HERE TO ASK YOUR LEGISLATORS TO PROTECT LAW-ABIDING PEOPLE BY AMENDING HOUSE BILL 9 AND CLOSING THE MEDIA ACCESS LOOPHOLE.

Related Story:
Two OH newsies buck media trend, call for close of Media Access Loophole

Suspect Wanted In Connection With Attack, Rape

WHIOTV.com in Dayton is reporting that Dayton police are searching for a man suspected in the brutal attack and rape of his ex-girlfriend just hours after he was released from jail on an unrelated charge, and despite there having been still another warrant out for his arrest.

From the story:

    Investigators said that early Monday morning, [Michael] Cohen led officers on a chase in Huber Heights. Officers eventually caught him and took him into custody.

    He was booked into the Montgomery County Jail and then released at 4:26 a.m. Authorities said that at 5 a.m., Cohen entered his ex-girlfriend's home while she was sleeping, beat her and then raped her.

    Police said Cohen was booked on a misdemeanor charge following the chase. Authorities said that a warrant had been issued for Cohen's arrest for a previous domestic violence charge, but were unable to find or verify the warrant before his release.

    Authorities were forced to release Cohen because of the misdemeanor chase charge. They said it was only after he was released that they eventually discovered his warrant.

Commentary from Senate District 10 Coordinator Larry S. Moore:
Another predator turned out on the streets and he strikes again! It only took him about 34 minutes of freedom to attack and ruin a woman's life! She has now become one of the "one in four women" who will suffer a violent attack in their lifetime.

The police and the courts are not keeping these predators in jail, out of society, or protecting anyone in cases like these. Anyone that does not take seriously their own means of self-defense is relying on a system that, while the best in the world, is seriously flawed and fails to protect citizens. Only you can protect you.

Criminal misuse of guns in Ohio – and the failure of gun control to stop it

Gun control has failed to make our streets safe, and funding cuts are forcing police departments to downsize. It is time for a new approach to crime deterrence.

  • Bucyrus: Bucyrus teens reportedly try to rob female classmate
    It wasn't a good Friday for two young wannabe robbers last week. Two Bucyrus boys, 15 and 16, tried to rob a 16-year-old classmate at gunpoint but got away, temporarily empty-handed. According to Bucyrus police Chief Ken Teets, the boys pulled a BB gun on the girl who was walking in the 500 block of South East Street around 10:30 a.m. "They asked her for her money and she said she had none, then they asked her if she had any drugs on her," Teets said, adding the girl said no. Police were called to the area and the girl said the gun looked like a 9mm. A Crawford County Sheriff's Office deputy saw the two boys who matched a description the girl gave police and officers converged on the two who gave up without any resistance. Both boys were taken to a Marion juvenile facility pending a Juvenile Court appearance. The incident was the [city’s] second armed robbery attempt in the city within the week.

    We were told these types of crimes would happen after OhioCCW became law...but of course, it is a near 100% certainty her attacker wasn't a CHL-holder.

  • Cincinnati: Woman shot in buttocks during random shooting
    Officials are investigating a report of a shooting in Over-The-Rhine Monday afternoon, News 5 reported. Details are sketchy, but investigators said a disabled woman was shot in the left thigh at 1523 Race St. at about 1 p.m. They believe the suspect was shooting randomly. The suspect was described as a black male. Witnesses said he was tall and slim. He was last seen wearing a black skull cap, gray hooded sweatshirt and blue jeans. The victim said he fled westbound on 15th Street. The victim was identified as Yvonne Williams, 39. She said the suspect shot at her three times, hitting her once.

    Ohio State Highway Patrol bureaucrats say this man should have been able to "just drive away" from his attacker.

  • Columbus: Carjackers Take Man's Hearing Aid
    A 53-year-old Columbus driver was beaten and left on the side of the road last Friday night. As it turns out, his attackers were after more than just the man’s car. It was a routine drive to the grocery store for Oscar Baylor. But before he could make it home, Baylor got carjacked. “It just happened so fast," Baylor described. “I was more shocked. I never thought nothing like this would happen to me." "Two guys just jumped in the car and started beating me,” Baylor said. Then, they dragged Baylor out of his 1991 red Pontiac Sunbird and left him lying on the ground with a broken nose and other fractures in his face, along with a sore hip. He was able to walk home, and then Baylor immediately went to the hospital. But Oscar says is the most frustrating part of being carjacked isn't that they took his car. He told 10TV the worst thing stolen in the altercation was his hearing aid, because now he can't hear. Oscar says hearing aids are expensive. He wonders if he'll be able to afford a new one. He says despite what happened, he's working on forgiving his attackers, even though he won't be able to forget.

    Statistically speaking, the only thing more dangerous than fighting back with anything other than a gun is to fight back with nothing at all. These people were lucky.

  • Columbus: Unarmed citizens disarm, apprehend armed robber
    Owners of a south side tobacco store put business aside and rushed outside to save the life of a man who got shot just steps from their door. It was a routine night at the Lockbourne Smoke Shop when the two brothers who own the business had a customer come in and alert them about trouble out front. "The guy who sells CD's outside… he just got shot!” Mahmoud al-Mahmoud described. “And he needs help, because they’re fighting outside!" The owners then heard a gunshot and, along with their cousin, ran outside to save the sidewalk vendor. "He tried to shoot a couple of bullets to scare us, but we were quicker. And I grabbed the gun from him, and we beat him down," al-Mahmoud explained. He and his brother held the shooting suspect down until police arrived. Investigators say the man not only shot the victim in the stomach, but was also trying to rob him. The attack was something the two men said they would not tolerate. "We want to keep our neighborhood safe,” Mohammed al-Mahmoud said. “And we can't let anybody get away with something like that." The man who was shot in the stomach was taken to Grant Medical Center. Columbus Police said he was in stable condition. Police arrested 19-year-old Shonte Alexander Gordon at the shooting scene. Robbery squad detectives were charging Gordon with aggravated robbery and felonious assault with a firearm.

    Human beings understand reason, compassion, and dignity. Predators understand strength.

  • Dayton: Man Beaten to Death Near His Home
    It's an unthinkable tragedy that outrages neighbors when a man is robbed of his wallet right in front of his home but then beaten and left for dead. 60 year old Fitz Payne was in the same block as his home when three teens accosted him and violently beat him. After a night at the hospital, Payne died. A police officer happened to be driving by at the time of the assault. He jumped out along the 2400 block of West Third to help Mr. Payne. While medics rushed him to the hospital police arrested three teens -- a 15 year old and two 16 year olds. They were arraigned on aggravated robbery charges Saturday in Juvenile Court. But now that Payne is dead they could face murder charges in adult court, a punishment that fits the crime, according to Payne's friends. “Out of control, what they did to him was senseless, and I don’t even call them kids, because you have to be an animal to do what they did,” said Efrim Goldsmith. “If you’re man enough to do the crime, you should be man enough to do the time. Don't be crying now, cause you should have known better before you even did it,” said Charles Lucas. Friends tell 2News that Payne was a Vietnam vet, a former member of the Black Panthers and a huge advocate for kids and teens in the area. That's why they find this crime so shocking. They say Payne probably knew and helped the very teens that are responsible for his murder.

    Company policies rendering employees defenseless keep the workplace safe, right?

  • Linwood: Man shot as he arrived at work
    The owner of Wine Cellar Innovations is in University Hospital today after being shot this morning as he arrived at work. Jim Dekenbach got to the office on Eastern Avenue a little after 7:30 a.m. Police say the gunman was waiting for him in the garage where Dekenbach parks. Dekenbach went inside the business, where someone called 911. He was shot in the stomach. His condition is not available. The business makes custom wine cellars and wine racks.

    The state says she is too young to be trusted with her right to bear arms for self-defense, but she wasn't too young for a predator…

  • Oxford: Miami U student raped, police say
    Oxford police are investigating a report of a rape Monday, News 5 reported. Officials said a 19-year-old Miami University student was inside the Stadium Bar, which is about one block from campus, with her attacker. The victim told investigators she had not met him before Saturday night. Police said as he was walking her home, he allegedly raped her in a nearby alley.

    When confronted by a dangerous criminal, it's safer just to run away, not try to protect yourself, right?

  • Toledo: Toledo man shot during botched robbery attempt
    A Toledo man was shot in his left leg last night during a bungled robbery attempt at the Southgate Circle Apartments on Southgate Circle Drive in South Toledo, police said. Joe Holston, 27, the victim of the robbery attempt whose address was not released, drove himself to Toledo Hospital, where no information about his condition was available last night. Mr. Holston told police he went to the apartment complex about 8 p.m. to visit a friend, but was confronted by an unknown man before he could get to the friend's apartment, Detective Lawrence Anderson said. The man reportedly told Mr. Holston to "give it all up," then drew a gun and shot Mr. Holston as the latter was backing up in order to run. The gunman then fled. Police had no suspects last night, Detective Anderson said.

    But what about the gun control laws that said he couldn't be in possession of a gun?

  • Zanesville: Zanesville man facing murder charge
    A Zanesville man has been arrested in connection with a murder in South Carolina, and two other local residents were arrested as accessories in the fatal shooting. Jeremy S. McGilton, 24, was charged Tuesday with murder for the fatal shooting of James Young, 24, of 2766 Oak Bay Drive, in Horry County, S.C. According to Sgt. Maurice Jones of the Horry County Police Department, the murder occurred around or after midnight Saturday at Young's residence. Jones said Young's fiancee returned from work around 2 a.m. Sunday, found Young dead and called the police. The investigation led to McGilton. Locally, McGilton was sentenced to seven months in prison in June 2004 for having a weapon under disability.